ABOUT US                     no.38

 

       EDITORIALS

 

       ARCHIV  

 

       FEEDBACK    

              

       LINKS  

 

       CONTACT US    

                 

        Free Updates

 

        Follow us on twitter

 

       number: thirty-eight

a web journal of urban and political affairs

 

You are here: Home

The New City aims to foster critical thinking and debate on the future of our cities and the disproportionate influence of inner-city thinking on urban planning and economic, social and environmental policy. Editors: John Muscat, Jeremy Gilling

 

Urban Diary: Jan Gehl's pedestrian ideas for Sydney ...  [enter]    

          

 

News Briefs                  [previous]

 

Light rail to push up house prices

 

First-home buyers like being on the

outer

 

Sprawl crawl as buyers look to greener pastures

 

New suburbs to ease rent squeeze across Sydney                                                  

 

 

 

         

The New City is catalogued in the National Library of Australia's Pandora Archive and has featured on:

 

On Line Opinion, Planetizen, Catallaxy, Demographia, New Geography, Quadrant Online, the National Post and Forbes.com.

 

  For the Working Class

An exposé of the real anti-working-class agenda by

Michael Thompson, the author of Labor Without Class ... more

The Urbanist's Guide to Kevin Rudd's Downfall

by John Muscat ... read it on New Geography

Ruining our cities to save them

 

Green city planning will make our

 urban problems worse, not better ... [more]

Joel Kotkin's  THE BROKEN LADDER

The threat to upward mobility in the global city

 

From one of the world's most original urbanists, a fresh insight

into developments which threaten to block opportunities

for advancement in three of the world's most dynamic cities ... [more]

The suburban economy and its enemies

 

     Beware those seeking to

strangle our once and future booming suburbs ... [more]

 

[38] 18 May 2010 / Mr Rudd's unproductive ideas on urban productivity

Kevin Rudd's compact city delusions shape his flawed

pronouncements on urban  productivity, which focus on transport costs to the exclusion of many other pressing cost inputs ... [more]

Republished by New Geography

 

 

Why is urban sprawl bad?:

Ross Elliott demolishes each of the flawed, though constantly repeated,

arguments against urban sprawl ... [more]

 

[37] 14 March 2010 / Ruining our cities to save them

 

Green urban planners and politicians are ramping up their campaign for more compact cities, but if they succeed the outcome will be less affordable housing, fewer jobs and horrendous traffic congestion ... [more]                                                   Republished by New Geography

 The Not-So-Lucky Country:

Writing in Forbes.com, Joel Kotkin backs The New City while nailing

Kevin Rudd as a darling of tertiary educated progressives ... [more]

For home buyers, no dream in Disneyland

 

We take aim at the welfare lobby's dangerous thinking on housing affordability ... [more]

 [36] 12 March 2010 / Sydney: choking in its own density  

 

Wendell Cox explains how Sydney's air quality is deteriorating due to flawed urban consolidation policies ... [more]

The trouble with George Street: While Sydney's Lord Mayor indulges her green fantasies, the CBD's main street shows worsening signs of blight, writes Miranda Devine ...

[more] and [more].

Dreams into nightmares: the housing affordability time bomb

 

Wendell Cox exposes some flawed thinking about the housing affordability crisis.

[35] 12 January 2010 / Copenhagen: the fall of Green Statism

 

Now we have the Copenhagen deniers. These are people who won't accept that the UN's climate change process has been derailed ... [more]                                                Republished by New Geography

The suburbs are sexy: Wendell Cox demolishes the flawed thinking behind the Obama administration's anti-suburban agenda ... [more]

Workers flee Sydney's unaffordable housing

 

Flawed land supply policies are squeezing workers out of Sydney's housing market ... [more]

 [34]  4 October 2009 / Toward the Great Australian Nightmare: a quarter floor in a high-rise block?

 

Wendell Cox demonstrates how home ownership is slipping away from essential workers like nurses, teachers and police and ambulance officers ... [more]

It's time for the burbs to be heard: We must listen to the silent majority who live in the suburban heartland, argues Bernard Salt ... [more]

Housing affordability: NZ and UK Labour show the ALP the way

 

Hugh Pavletich argues the ALP should follow its UK and NZ counterparts.

 [33] 10 September 2009 / The crisis of academic urban planning

 

A wide gulf has opened up between mainstream Australian values and the prescriptions of our urban planning academics ... [more]

Forcing density in Australia's suburbs: Tony Recsei explains why there should be little support for higher density Smart Growth ideologies in the Australian context ... [more]

Is environmental sustainability socially unsustainable?

 

Misuse of the term 'sustainability' is threatening living standards ... [more]

So Australian cities are environmental hell holes?

 

Mercer's 2009 Quality of Living Survey ranks Sydney the tenth and Melbourne the eighteenth most liveable cities in the world while Melbourne ranks third and Sydney ninth on The Economist Intelligence Unit's 2009 liveability ranking.

Planning Never Never Land?: Trying to contain future sprawl in South East Queensland is a physical impossibility: the numbers don't add up, writes Ross Eliott ... [more]

The Herald campaigns for Sydney as East Berlin   

 

The Sydney Morning Herald's 'campaign for Sydney' was for no one but its narrow band of inner-city readers ... [more]

    

How elite environmentalists are impoverishing blue-collar Americans:   Joel Kotkin delivers a timely warning on how green agendas can hurt workers ... [more]

The Chinese Century

 

    A series of commentaries on the implications for Sydney of China's rise ... [enter]

[32]  25 June 2009 / Bulldozing the 'burbs or bulldozing the truth?

 

The green school of journalism plays fast and loose with the evidence in its rush to report the decline and fall of suburbia ... [more]

Sydney: from world city to 'sick man' of Australia: The 'Great Australian Dream' of home ownership is being extinguished, says Wendell Cox, especially in Sydney ... [more]

 Links of Interest

 

Acton Institute

 

Anholt City Brands Index

[31]  30 March 2009 / Suburbs and climate change: a  homegrown brawl

 

A war of words has erupted over research suggesting that low-density suburbs may not be as bad for climate change as environmentalists and planners so often insist ... [more]

Humanity can't power progress with green faith: Environmentalists who oppose everything but renewable energy are condemning billions to poverty, writes Martin Ferguson ... [more]

Auda-city

 

Australian Housing and

Urban Research Institute

 

Bernard Salt

[30]  2 November 2008 / Stay rational on climate change

 

Labels like "climate sceptic" don't make for sound decision-making ... [more]

Obsessive housing disorder: Steven Malanga explains how nearly a

century of Washington's efforts to promote homeownership has

produced one calamity after

another ... [more]

Center for Urban Economic Development

 

Centre for Independent Studies

 

Centre for Population and Urban Research - Monash University

[29]  28 September 2008 / Surging Greens peddle hypocrisy

 

Presenting themselves as high-minded crusaders, the Greens appeal to the narrowest of narrow self-interest ... [more]

 

Replacing Fatropolis with Fit Towns: Plans to redesign our towns as 'fit towns' are turning into something very repressive, writes Tim Black ... [more]

Cityfutures

 

City Journal

 

City Mayors

[28]  14 August 2008 / On the Australian housing shortage

 

Wendell Cox delivers the plain truth that housing shortages are the product of deliberate policy ... [more]

The housing bubble: the planner's role and lessons learned: Restrictions on expansion into urban peripheries have fed the global housing bubble, says Hugh Pavletich ... [more]

Counterpoint

 

Cyburbia

 

Demographia

[27]  1 July 2008 / Why carbon trading and why now? 

 

The government should rethink its commitment to, or timetable for, an emissions trading scheme ... [more]

Liberate shopping centres: Ease planning restrictions on shopping centres and retail prices will fall, argues Professor Allan Fels ... [more]

Demographia (Blog)

 

Globalisation and World Cities

 

Houston Strategies

[26]  22 March 2008 / Here comes Sydney's yuppie carousel

 

Morris Iemma's North West Metro is fine as an infrastructure project but fares less well as a strategic investment ... [more]

Houston, New York has a problem: The southern city welcomes the middle class; heavily regulated and

expensive Gotham drives it away, writes Edward Glaeser ...  [more]

Institute of Public Affairs

 

Infrastructure Australia

 

Institute of Transport and Logistics Studies - Sydney University

[25]  January 2008 / Green Labor or blue-collar betrayal?

 

That Labor’s return to office would be framed in grandiose terms, as a watershed shift from social conservatism to progressivism, was easy to predict ... [continue] 

From gays to Nerdistan: Bernard Salt explains how urban vitality may owe more to hi-tech nerds than hip creative types ... [more]

Joel Kotkin

 

Journal of Urban Affairs

 

Market Urbanism

[24]  Nov-Dec 2007 / Howard: enter stage dry, exit stage wet

 

Unlike many commentators, ranging from Alan Ramsey to Imre Saluszinsky, we don’t think Saturday’s election result is a foregone conclusion ... [continue]

Dark green barbarians: Green superstition and mysticism are prevailing over rational thinking, argues Craig Emerson ... [more]

Megacities Foundation

 

Melbourne Institute for Applied Economic and Social Research

 

Melbourne 2030

[23]  Sep-Oct 2007 / Skills and collaboration, not WorkChoices, deliver economic success

 

In our March 2007 editorial, we said that compared to the prime years of economic reform and responsibility under Bob Hawke and Paul Keating in the 1980s and early 1990s, the Howard Government’s economic record has been patchy at best ... [continue]

Orbital is the way to go: In a city where jobs are scattered, Sydney's tollways are doing a good job, writes Michael Duffy. We need more of them ... [more]

Metropolis

 

Metropolis Magazine

 

Metropolitan Policy Program - Brookings Institution

[22]  August 2007 / If housing depends on a vision for our cities, try ‘opportunity urbanism’

 

A much quoted assertion in the housing debate came from Rory Robertson, financial analyst at Macquarie Bank ... [continue]

The fourth Demographia housing affordability survey: The latest Demographia survey confirms that Australian houses are still amongst

 the least affordable in the English-speaking world ... [more]

Michael Duffy

 

Motoring Blog (NRMA)

 

National Centre for Social and Economic Modelling - NATSEM

[21]  June - July 2007 / Value judgements, conflicting assumptions undermine Climate Institute ‘research’

 

On 28 May, ABC radio bulletins were abuzz with news of new research ... [continue]

London: still stuck in a jam: Nico McDonald explains why London's congestion charge has not been as useful as its advocates claim.

National Roads and Motorists' Association

 

Network City (Perth)

 

New Geography

[20]  May 2007 / Coal mining will outlast green hysterics

 

‘Not all jobs are good’, says former Liberal Party leader John Hewson ... [continue]
 

We'll never get to Kyoto by transit: Proposals to replace cars with public transport will fail, argues Wendell Cox. They will never be an answer to greenhouse-gas emissions.

Next American City

 

NSW Department of Infrastructure, Planning and Natural Resources

 

NSW Department of Housing

[19]  April 2007 / Carbon trading hasn't worked - mandate clean technologies

 

A delusional fog seems to have descended on climate change policymaking in Australia ... [continue]     

In praise of big cities: James Woudhuysen demolishes The Urban Environment, a recent UK report that says cities make us sick. 

On Line Opinion

 

People and Place

 

Performance Urban Planning

[18]  March  2007 /  Labor can relive its economic glory days

 

With Labor under Kevin Rudd currently enjoying a stratospheric lead in the opinion polls, there are no doubt many who think the election is done and dusted ... [continue]

In praise of chain stores: Chain stores aren't destroying local flavour, says Virginia Postrel, they're providing variety and comfort.

Peter Gordon's Blog

 

Planetizen

 

Planning Institute of Australia

[17]  February 2007 / Workers flee Sydney's unaffordable housing

 

‘Sydney must stop growing sooner or later’, demanded Clive Hamilton of the Australia Institute recently ... [continue]

The public transport myth: Despite the urgings of elite opinion makers, observes Alan Moran, public transport has never been less relevant or popular.

Radical Urban Theory

 

Reason Online

 

Robert Bruegmann

[16]  Dec 06- Jan 07 / Green judiciary a looming menace to workers

 

If you believe judges should decide every case on its merits, if you believe this is an essential feature of the judicial function, be concerned ... [continue] 

ABC's Counterpoint tackles urban consolidation: ABC Radio National's Counterpoint program presents Michael Warby and Wendell Cox on the negative consequences of land rationing and urban consolidation.

South East Queensland Regional Plan

 

Spiked

 

Sydney Metropolitan Strategy

[15]  November 2006 /  Don't sacrifice workers on altar of climate change

 

According to a recent Climate Institute survey, 54 per cent of rural Australians believe the government should do more to reduce climate change ... [continue]

Why Perth is booming: Joel Kotkin explains that the culturally savvy, 'hip' cities of the dot com era such as Sydney are losing ground to the new boomtowns fueled by high energy prices, like Perth.

Sydney Morning Herald

 

The Daily Telegraph

 

The Manhattan Institute

[14]  October 2006 / Progressivism now a preserve of the privileged

 

There are two more books on a familiar theme: growing numbers of the upper middle-class are turning progressive ... [continue]  

How the suburbs made us rich: Without the suburbs, our parents and grandparents would have paid rent most of their lives, and the equity that so many aspirations depend on would not have developed, suggests Wendell Cox.

Tollroads News

 

Transport and Population Data Centre (NSW)

 

UN-Habitat

[13] September 2006 / Labor’s presidency hijacked by activists

‘The road to hell is paved with good intentions’. That proverb readily came to mind when Senator John Faulkner announced his intention to stand for Labor’s national presidency ... [continue]

The dead-weight of planning restraints: In Australia and elsewhere, urban planning has ceased to respond to individual needs and preferences but follows a central plan instead, writes Alan Moran.

Urban Age

 

Urban Development Institute of Australia - NSW

[12]   August 2006 /  Blogosphere has little to offer Labor

 

It took a while – going on a year – but The New City is finally being noticed by the ’blogs ... [continue]

How sprawl got a bad name: Robert Bruegmann believes that worries about sprawl have become so vivid not because conditions are so good. Soaring expectations are the real cause.

Urban Frontiers Program - University of Western Sydney

 

Urban Futures

 

Urban Jungle

[11]  July 2006 / Farewell to the tree-hugging premiers: state Labor’s new course

Interviewed recently about a book on his term as premier of New South Wales from 1976 to 1986, Neville Wran was asked to nominate his greatest achievement ...
[continue]

Farewell to the city?: Ignore the New Urbanists and nostalgics - the end of the boundary between town and country is a liberation, not a loss, says James Heartfield.

Urban Magazine

 

Urban Research Program - Griffith University

 

Urban Studies

[10]  June 2006 / The suburban economy and its enemies

 

Treasury Secretary Ken Henry’s recent address to business economists was an apt prism through which to survey Sydney’s immediate past and distant future ... [continue]

The curse of the creative class: Richard Florida's book The Rise of the Creative Class made him the darling of inner-city progressives. Steven Malanga begs to differ.

Urban Taskforce Australia

 

Virginia Postrel

 

Western Sydney Regional Organisation of Councils

[9]  May 2006 / Exposing the left’s strange economic hyper-rationalism

 

‘Bourgeois bohemians’ is how American writer David Brooks describes the new elite “of highly educated folk who have one foot in the bohemian world of creativity and another in the bourgeois realm of ambition and worldly success”... [continue]

Nimbies, Yobs and Lebs: Quadrant magazine argues that Nimbyism is now one of the most obnoxious features of modern communities. It is the triumph of localism and parish pump politics over wider concerns.

 

[8]  April 2006 / A caucus of Carmens? Some thoughts on Labor’s  ‘insoluble’ problem

 

Most Labor supporters are happy to consign The Latham Diaries to the dustbin of history... [continue]

Costly and cumbersome: it's time to get off the light rail bandwagon: Former Director-General of the NSW Ministry of Transport, John Lee, demolishes the trendy case for a light rail line into Sydney's CBD.

 

[7]  March 2006 / Is environmental sustainability socially unsustainable? 

 

Save-Our-Suburbs is the umbrella group for a small army of resident action groups across Sydney ... [continue]

Uncool cities: Joel Kotkin explains that, civic authorities believe the key to urban prosperity is appealing to the "hip set" but the only evidence for this comes from the dot-com boom of the late 1990's - and that time is over.

 

[6]  January 2006 /  “Rocky” Iemma dodges the green corner

Shortly before Bob Carr's retirement, an unnamed infrastructure consultant was quoted in the Australian Financial Review as follows: "Sydney is dying of NIMBYISM (not in my backyard)"...
[continue]

Prices and planning: the state of the housing industry: Alan Moran finds that the high cost of Sydney housing relates to the scarcity value created by urban planning and the imposts on developers of government regulations

 

[5]  October 2005 /  The final repudiation of Ben Chifley

 

“Indeed a better question for tonight's discussion might have been ‘would Ben Chifley be a train driver today?’" ...  [continue]

Sydney isn't full, so let's stop the rot: Michael Duffy argues the indiscriminate push for urban consolidation, though based on flawed assumptions, is turning Sydney into an unaffordable rat's nest

 
 

[4]  August 2005 / Nuclear energy power for the people?

 

We do not pretend to any particular expertise on nuclear energy (although we think it a pity that other outspoken commentators are not similarly candid) ... [continue]

 
 

[3]  June 2005 / Labor and refugees - clear vision in the eye of the storm

 

The shadow Minister for Immigration, Laurie Ferguson, deserves great credit for his efforts to find the space to honour Australia’s, and Labor’s, international legal and moral obligations ... [continue]

 
 

[2]  March 2005 / Tax dollars keep the inner city dream alive

 

Our last editorial pointed out that a crucial difference between Labor and the conservative parties is that the ALP’s policies and pronouncements are out of kilter with (well to the left of) the views of Labor voters  ... [continue]

 
 

[1]  January 2005 / Winning back the disenchanted

 

Labor has now lost four Federal elections in a row – its worst run since the Menzies era ... [continue]